2010-12-20

Influences Ansel Adams Revisited

In my earlier post,  Ansel Adams post one , I gave my initial initial impressions of Adams work. I have subsequently continued to review his photographs. I have also recently obtained two books which make comments on his work and place it within the context of the landscape genre. These are American Landscapes Photographs from the Collection of the Museum of Modern Art and Ansel Adams at 100. Both books are by John Szarkowski the renowned Director of Photography at MOMA in New York and were the accompanying books for Exhibitions.

American Lanscapes Photographs from the Collection of the Museum of Modern Art traces the history of American Landscape photography from its beginning until the 1970s through the museums own collection. It allowed me to consider where Adams sits in the broader context of American Landscape photography.

The early pioneers were the likes of Timothy O'Sullivan who had made his name as a documentary photographer of the American Civil War. O'Sullivan was hired to take photographs as part of a scientific expedition. However there is evidence that O'Sullivan had made aesthetic judgements vis a vis the framing of his subjects and so his work might now be viewed as not simply scientific in nature.

These early pioneers were followed by the likes of Muybridge and Carleton Watkins operated less as explorers and more as 'laureate(s) memorialising known wonders', devising creative strategies for depicting well known motifs in a fresh manner.

Thereafter followed great photographers such as the young Edward Steichen working in a Pictorialist mode, seeking to emulate the art of painting, with inviting subjects, soft focus and movement.

The Pictorialist ethic was roundly rejected by Modernists such as Edward Weston, although Weston himself was intimidated by the chaotic nature of nature. Starting with intimate landscapes Weston, Strand and others gradually tackled the wider landscape from the standpoint of formal integrity which represents the Modernist approach. They emphasised process and form above subject.

Whilst a Modernist, emphasising the perfection of the process - perhaps more than any other photographer - Ansel Adams has his own unique style. His greatest works visualise the landscape as an Event - a temporary piece of theatre created by the majesty of the scene, the light and the weather. Here is an Adams photograph from the exhibition:

Oak Tree Snow Storm, Yosemite 1948 by Ansel Adams
























I chose this image because I am sitting in my study writing this post with snow all around our house. I have been outside taking some shots of snow covered trees also. It is interesting to see that Adams has retained a range of tonal values within the snow, giving it shape and texture. I have included one of my own images below to compare.

Snow covered Tree, Burnham by Keith Greenough
























The tonal range of the highlights in my image is much more compressed. It is also clear that the tree itself if much less attractive - no leaves, less elegant, less symmetrical. My image also has less background interest.  The difference in tonal range is clearly seen when the histograms for the two images are compared...

Adams







Greenough







I have much still to learn.

The second book I have reviewed is Ansel Adams at 100. This is another catalogue from an Exhibition curated by John Szarkowski. This time the exhibition was staged by the San Francisco Museum of Modern art - an organisation which Adams had much involvement with. The book provides an interesting essay which traces Adams development as a photographer.

It was interesting to hear Szarkowski's view that Adams work varied from the superlative to the mediocre. He was particularly disparaging about Adams work outside of the landscape genre.

As a 'straight' photographer Adams work depended on both shape and texture. Interestingly it was Szarkowski's view that Adams work moved from being described very much in graphic terms in the mid thirties to becoming increasingly dependent on perfection of the tonal range some ten years later. He suggested that this might become abundantly clear if one were to take an earlier and later image and compare them when they are reduced to postage stamp size. The former whilst damaged would still be intelligible the latter most likely would be unintelligible. I thought I would try this as an experiment. The two photographs are:

Mount Robson, Jasper National Park
Canada, 1928 by Ansel Adams
























Cleaing Winter Storm, Yosemite Valley, 1942 by Ansel Adams




















Here are the two images as postage stamps...










I think this proves the point which from my own perspective shows how important the management of tone is in creating an atmospheric image. Graphic designs is important in composition but light and tone can create more subtle and emotive image. As is waiting for the moment of theatre which will lead to the exceptional image.

I will wind up this with another of my favourite Adams images, Lake and Cliffs Sierra Nevada 1932. This is a very graphic image - perhaps reflecting a personal bias. I selected this image because it is intriguing. It is hard to make out what it is. I love the variation in tone and texture which are fantastic and the way he has captured the reflections in the still water of the lake. It  has a very flat perspective which adds to the abstract nature and its appeal. It is wonderful to realise that nature can offer such glorious scenes of abstract design.

Lake and Cliffs, Sierra Nevada 1932 by Ansel Adams

No comments:

Post a Comment

Labels

28mm Elmarit 50mm Summicron accreditation Alex Soth American West Ansel Adams Art of Snapshot as Assignment Assignment Four Assignment One Assignment Two ball head Beauty Berkshire black and white Brighton Photo Biennial 2010 british museum Buckinghamshire Burnham Beeches Canada Caponigro Central St Martins Charlie Waite city Cliveden cloud Club La Santa collage competition composition course criticism Daisy Gilardini David Alan Harvey davidnoton derby detail Dorset drama dusk exhibition f/64 Famara Fay Godwin Feedback Fernando Gomez figures Filters format framing Framing foreground interest composition Freeman Gabriele Basilico galen rowell Georgia O'Keefe grain Hambleden Harrison Hot Springs hawaii influence ironman Jasper Joel Meyerowitz John Davies Kingston Lacey Lake District Landscape landscape format Languedoc Lanzarote LEARNING LOG-April2010 LEARNING LOG-April2011 LEARNING LOG-August2010 LEARNING LOG-August2011 LEARNING LOG-December2010 LEARNING LOG-Feb2010 LEARNING LOG-February-2011 LEARNING LOG-January-2011 LEARNING LOG-July2010 LEARNING LOG-June2010 LEARNING LOG-June2011 LEARNING LOG-March-2011 LEARNING LOG-March2010 LEARNING LOG-March2011 LEARNING LOG-May2010 LEARNING LOG-May2011 LEARNING LOG-November2010 LEARNING LOG-October 2010 LEARNING LOG-September2010 leica Lely's Venus lenses light Light Science and Magic london LPOY2010 Malhotra man-made Marc Garanger Martin Parr Mirrors and Windows Mississippi Molly Landreth MOMA moon National Media Museum National Trust near and far Nick Gleis OCA one acre opening Overton Hill panorama perspective Phil Malpas photographer polariser Portfolio portrait format portraits post-modern projects Quotation realism Rinko Kawauchi Robert Adams royalphotographicsociety Running seasons Silhouette sky snow soft colour soft light Stephen Gill street street 35mm Summicron Studland style Sunrise Szarkowski team telephoto Terri Weifenbach test Timanfaya trees triathlon tripod TriUK Tutor two UK Urban Development USA water Watlington Hill weareoca West Kennett Western Art Weston wide angle Windsor Workshop Yosemite

About Me

I have been taking photographs since I was young boy some 45 years ago, but only seriously since 2005 when I enrolled to study at the Open College of the Arts. I am working towards a BA in Photography. I am a Licentiate of the Royal Photographic Society. This log record details of my projects and assignments during my studies. It also records ideas, work by other artists/photographers, notes on books/websites/exhibitions, influences, discoveries, thoughts, research findings and observations as I work through my courses. You can contact me at keith.greenough@btinternet.com or simply leave a comment on one of my posts.

Landscape Photography Bibliography

  • Andrea G Stillman (2007), Ansel Adams 400 Photographs, Little Brown New York USA
  • Andy Grundberg (1999), Crisis of the Real, Aperture Foundation New York
  • Ansel Adams (2007), Examples The Making of 40 Photographs, Little Brown New York USA
  • Ben Maddow(1989), Edward Weston, His Life, Aperture Foundation New York USA
  • Charlie Waite (1989), Scottish Islands, Constable London
  • Charlie Waite (1992), The Making of Landscape Photographs, Collins and Brown London
  • Charlie Waite (1999), Seeing Landscapes, Collins and Brown London
  • Charlie Waite (2002), In My Minds Eye, Photographers Institute Press East Sussex UK
  • Charlie Waite (2005), Landscape, Collins and Brown London
  • Clive Minnitt and Phil Malpas(2009), Finding the Picture, Envisage Books London
  • David Noton (2008), PHOTOGRAPY ESSENTIALS: WAITING FOR THE LIGHT, David & Charles PLC, London
  • Fay Godwin(1985), Land, William Heinemann London
  • Fay Godwin(1990), Our Forbidden Land, Jonathan Cape London
  • Fay Godwin(1998), Glassworks & Secret Lives, Stella Press East Sussex UK
  • Fay Godwin(2001), Landmarks, Dewi Lewis Publishing Stockport UK
  • Galen Rowell (1995), Mountain Light, Sierra Club Books San Francisco USA
  • Galen Rowell (2001), Inner Game of Outdoor Photography, Norton & co New York USA
  • Galen Rowell (2002),Galen Rowell's Vision: The Art of Adventure Photography, University of California Press USA
  • Harry Callaghan (1993), Ansell Adams in Color, Little Brown New York USA
  • Hunter, Biver & Fuqua(2007), Light Science & Magic, Elsevier Oxford UK
  • James Bentley & Charlie Waite (1987), Languedoc, George Philip London
  • James Bentley & Charlie Waite (1987), Languedoc, George Philip London
  • Joe Cornish, Charlie Waite, David Ward, Eddie Ephraums (2006), Working the Light, Argentum London
  • Joe Cornish, Charlie Waite, David Ward, Eddie Ephraums (2007), Developing Style and Vision, Argentum London
  • Joel Meyerowitz (2002), Cape Light, Little Brown and Company New York USA
  • John Berger, Ways of Seeing, Penguin Modern Classics
  • John P Schaefer (2007),The Ansel Adams Guide Book 2 Basic Techniques of Photography, Little Brown New York USA
  • John P Schaefer (2007),The Ansel Adams Guide Book I Basic Techniques of Photography, Little Brown New York USA
  • John Szarkowski (1981), American Landscapes, The Museum of Modern Art New York USA
  • Landscape Photographer of the Year Collection 01 (2007), AA Publishing
  • Landscape Photographer of the Year Collection 02 (2008), AA Publishing
  • Landscape Photographer of the Year Collection 03 (2009), AA Publishing
  • Liz Wells (1996), Photography:A Critical Introduction, Routledge Oxon
  • Liz Wells (2003), The Photography Reader, Routledge Oxon
  • Marc Garanger (1989), Louisiane, Kodak
  • Robert Adams (1996), Beauty in Photography, Aperture Foundation New York USA
  • Robert Adams et al (2009), New Topographics, Steidl Germany
  • Stephen Shaw (2004), Uncommon Places The Complete Works, Thames and Hudson, London
  • Susan Sontag, On Photography, Penguin Books London
  • Terence Pitts (2008), Edward Weston (Icons Series), Taschen
  • TPOTY Awards (2010), TRAVEL PHOTOGRAPHER OF THE YEAR Journey Three, Travel Photographer of the Year Suffolk UK

Followers